-Know how to monitor and evaluate a community music-making
project.
Monitoring and evaluation: reasons for evaluation eg reporting to funders, observing, evaluating against objectives (at workshop and project level), using evaluations in future planning; evaluation techniques eg questionnaires, interviews, external evaluation teams, feeding back, report writing, action for futureEvaluation for my Workshop at Harpsden village hall
I'm going to evaluate my workshop for my workshop that I held with Daisy at Harpsden village hall. I'm going to talk about how I think it went, what I didn't think so well and what I'd change if I were to do it again. I'm going to include things like interviews that I had with the people that run the mother and toddlers group and also a video which Daisy and I have taken to give a spoken evaluation on how we feel it went and what factors we also didn't feel went so well.
- They all definitely had fun and enjoyed singing the songs.
- Everyone got involved and no children caused a fuss and refused to join in.
- We let them get involved by choosing songs that they enjoy to sing.
- We introduced ourselves at the beginning of the workshop and everyone was really understanding to us and one lady in particular was incredibly helpful by keeping an eye out of the children just in case they did play up as we were knew to this.
- It was very difficult for me (and Daisy) to introduce a song that they didn't know as they were very young they most definitely didn't want to learn anything else.
- We couldn't really stick to our original plan, this was because when we were actually up there it was much different to how it actually looked, it was much more difficult.
- It wasn't very clear that Daisy and I were taking charge of separate things, this was due to the fact they were quite difficult to handle as it isn't something we are used to, so we had to really both take charge and do it all more in a pair then do things by ourselves. I think it was the age range that made it hard for us, perhaps if they were a bit older it would have been easier and more clear on the video that we both took charge for different things.
What I'd do differently next time:
- Try and control them better perhaps, although it was incredibly difficult and I don't think the parents helped that they were just sat about chatting and not really doing anything, although some of them did get involved.
- Stick more to my original plan, but obviously things don't always go to plan and it was definitely a shock to us when we started to teach us.
- When Daisy and I went the first week to see how everything was and what to expect and to see what went on it wasn't the same as when we held the workshop. This may have been because they didn't know us so they felt they could play up a bit, so I think we should have thought of a plan to do if things didn't go quite to plan.
- Be more confident and enthusiastic.
- Do the workshop to slightly older children due to the fact it being very hard to work with them, they all fight for attention off you as you're older than them and the 'teacher' in their eyes so it can be very hard to try and take them all into account to try and please them all by singing the songs they want to sing.
- Do it completely by myself as it was difficult to let each other be in charge so we both just did it at the same time.
How I think it went overall:
On a whole it went fairly well, the main thing that I wanted to get out of it was experience on allowing children to have fun by singing songs that they enjoy and even introducing some them that they are't familiar with. I don't feel as if I did as well as I could have done, I was quite thrown back by the amount of children there was there (the week before there wasn't as many as there was the week we held the workshop), I also don't feel as if I was as enthusiastic as I could have been. I'm not used to being around children this young so I wasn't entirely sure how to act towards them, it was also very nerve wrecking having the parents just sit there and watch us. So if I was to do it again I definitely would choose a slightly older age range.
My objectives for my project and how well I achieved them:
On a whole it went fairly well, the main thing that I wanted to get out of it was experience on allowing children to have fun by singing songs that they enjoy and even introducing some them that they are't familiar with. I don't feel as if I did as well as I could have done, I was quite thrown back by the amount of children there was there (the week before there wasn't as many as there was the week we held the workshop), I also don't feel as if I was as enthusiastic as I could have been. I'm not used to being around children this young so I wasn't entirely sure how to act towards them, it was also very nerve wrecking having the parents just sit there and watch us. So if I was to do it again I definitely would choose a slightly older age range.
My objectives for my project and how well I achieved them:
- Research- I personally think that I did my research well although I think that I could have pushed this a little further.
- My research into nursery rhymes- I think I did this well because I looked at websites which had information about nursery rhymes, I already had some knowledge of them and we also went to the mother and toddlers group (Harpsden Hoppers) where we help the workshop the week before just to have a look at how they did it and what kinds of songs they're into and what they know.
What I could have done to have achieved my project objectives to a higher level:
- Research- Research wise I think I could have visited other workshops around my area (although I did go to Harpsden Hoppers the previous week to see how it was) and see how they work or I could have even watched YouTube videos and seen some footage of how other people hold workshops for people with the age range that I worked with. I could have also gone onto YouTube again and looked at other workshops and see what songs they sing their just to widen my variety.
- My research into nursery rhymes- I could have handed out a survey and sent it around to people that I know with young children and to other nurseries around my area, doing this would have given me more of an idea of what kinds of songs children enjoy because it will be different to when I was a toddler.
My objectives for my workshop and how well I achieved them:
INTERVIEW:- Teach them some songs- This didn't go to plan at all really, due to it being really difficult for me and Daisy to introduce them to something new together it would have been even harder to do that individually without each others help of controlling the children. It was a lot more harder than I expected and actually quite overwhelming and can knock you back a bit. As they were very young it was very hard to teach them something new as they are stuck in their ways and want to just do things that they already know.
- Introduce new movements to songs they already know- When we started the workshop we straight away realised that this would be impossible, it would have confused them changing the movements to songs that they already knew and seemed to only want to do songs that they knew and enjoyed. I think that we could have been more positive and given it more of a go because they may have actually been really willing to do this but we just felt it wasn't right but if it was an older age range I would definitely experiment much more and be more confident, so if I was to do it again I would do this.
- Make sure that they enjoy their selves and have fun- This is one of the ones that we were really proud that we achieved, they all had loads of fun and really enjoyed the sing along. There was one boy in particular that got very upset when certain songs weren't chosen but I think we dealt with that well by working around it to try and keep them all happy but we didn't want to let him get his own way because then this may have upset the other children so we compromised.
- Get them all involved and participating- They all did this with no problem at all, some were more difficult than others but they all got involved.
What I could have done to achieve my workshop objectives at a higher level:
- Teach them some songs- This being the initial idea of the project I think in order for me to achieve this next time I would have been more confident in teaching them, even if I just did a song they are already aware of and change a couple of the movements. It felt like it went really quick and it was really rushed and it makes you forget everything that you were initially supposed to do because there is so much going on but for next time I would definitely be more prepared.
- Introduce new movements to songs they already know- I don't think I would have even put this down as an objective next time as introducing a completely different set of movements to a song they already know off by heart would confuse them but I could still have just changed a couple because it still gets them thinking and they would have actually learned something.
- Make sure that they enjoy their selves and have fun- They all definitely had fun and this was something that I cared about the most. If they didn't have fun then I would have been really disappointed. I could have been more enthusiastic but as I said before it was actually rather overwhelming.
I interviewed Laura who runs the mother and toddlers group. Below is the interview, the questions I asked and her answers.
Questions
1. Why do you run this mother and toddlers group ?
2. Are the parents helpful ?
3. How long has 'Harpsden Hoppers' been going on for ?
4. Do you have any children yourself ?
5. Is the club expensive to run ?
Answers
1. I'm a mum of 4 myself and just really enjoy being around kids and setting up activities to do as I know quite a lot from my experience of being a mum. I do a lot of volunteering as well as this and love to help others.
2. The parents are okay on average they sometimes are a bit chatty but I would say they do help to keep their children behaving well.
3. About 3 years.
4. Yeah I have 4 children, 2 boys and 2 girls, my 2 girls come to the group with me.
5. The rental of the hall has gone up over the years, it's £35 now. I wouldn't say it's overly expensive but considering to start off it was about £8 and it has gone up an incredible amount.
Below is an interview which Daisy did with Clare who runs the mother and toddlers group along side Laura.
VIDEO DISCUSSION WITH DAISY:
Me and Daisy discussed how we thought the session went.
Questions we asked each other:
1) How do you feel the session went?
2) What do you think went well?
3) What didn't go so well?
4) What would you do next time and why?
VIDEO OF DISCUSSION FROM DAISY AND I:
I thought it would be a good idea to ask Laura and Clare how they think the workshop went:
Questions
1) How do you think Daisy and I did during the workshop, for example, how did we deal with the children?
2) Do you think the children enjoyed our workshop?
3) What do you think we could improve for next time, what didn't we do so well?
4) What did we do well?
Answers
1) I think you both did very well considering the situation that you were in. I think you could have both taken it in turns to take it the session, but considering what happened you did deal with it well.
2) I think they really enjoyed the workshop that you both held. You can tell by watching the video that they all really loved it. It was good for them to experience having another teacher for a change which was good for them, but this could be the reason that they played up a bit.
3) I think you could have perhaps been a bit more confident and enthusiastic.
4) You did well by getting them involved well and they all really enjoyed the songs that you sang with them. You spoke to them in the right manor and although they did play up a bit you both handled it very well. You both worked well together, for example, you didn't speak over each other and it seemed well planned and thought out.
I also sent out letters to the parents which has a questionnaire on it which had questions asking how they think we did and if their children enjoyed the workshop.
Future planning for next time
Next time I would:
- Go onto YouTube and compare how people hold workshops so this could have given me some inspiration and some ideas.
- Create several plans just in case it didn't go to plan, just like mine didn't go completely well.
- Go and visit other places like nurseries and schools and go to other places that hold workshops and see how people do them in different ways.
- Be more confident
- Definitely teach a younger age range
- Perhaps a smaller group as there was a lot of them it was hard for Daisy and I to take it in turns to teach
Video footage of workshop - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1P0SVLSXWgQ













.jpg)



















